data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8105d/8105d0c0396f1fa1044337b4cf6c52e5f9018a98" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2f994/2f994c544b9248249ec08a0677fffc7450a9df31" alt=""
Like its sister restaurant, Gotham Steakhouse, Hy’s offers a terrific afternoon happy hour in its bar. You can get a multi-course feast of snacks, cocktails, and wine for well under $200 per couple, which is much less than lunch or dinner here.
We started with the prawn cocktail, four large and very fresh prawns served with an excellent cocktail sauce. The we had the “famous” cheese toast, which is butter-grilled with a layer of cheese on top, and served in aluminum foil to keep it warm.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dfd5b/dfd5b786fa3d6d22ac908914fea688765bcda08c" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/98619/9861962c08fb31a6911ec9f25ba6b30ffa29d563" alt=""
Our mains were the mini lobster rolls, which came on grilled feather-light brioche, and the prime rib sliders, the most substantial dish. Each slider included a wonderful onion ring, encouraging us to make a note to order onion rings as a side next time.
In addition to the great drink prices such as 40% off sparkling wines during happy hour, the dessert menu prices are also very reasonable. We had tableside Bananas Foster and Irish Coffee. Both were prepared in true classic fashion.
The bar area is cozy, with only a few tables, but I think I like the ambiance at Gotham’s larger bar better. But both are excellent choices for an afternoon meal.